Organic Food Debate: New Study Reveals Health Implications for Farmland Birds
A recent study conducted by researchers at the Chizé Biological Studies Center and the Biogéosciences laboratory has cast doubt on the health benefits of organic food, particularly for farmland birds such as the grey partridge. Published in Environmental Pollution in 2021, the study found that birds fed conventionally grown grains showed significant differences in their immune systems, reproductive health, and body composition compared to those fed organically grown grains.
The researchers, led by biologist Jérôme Moreau, raised two groups of grey partridges with different diets: one group was fed organically grown wheat and corn, while the other was given conventionally farmed grains. The results showed that the conventional birds had unbalanced immune systems, lower red blood cell counts, and increased intestinal parasites. Female conventional birds also laid smaller eggs with thinner shells, built up more body fat, and became heavier than their organic counterparts.
In a 2023 follow-up study, the researchers found that feeding these birds conventionally reduced their ability to fly and lowered their vigilance. This could indicate potential repercussions on the birds' central nervous system.
These findings are in line with older animal studies that have also shown adverse effects of synthetic pesticides and fertilizers on reproductive health and survival rates. In 2009, a study published by Alberta Velimirov found similar results in rats, rabbits, chickens, and cattle, while two German researchers observed improved sperm motility in bulls fed hay grown without synthetic fertilizers.
The study's lead author, Jérôme Moreau, explained that the presence of heavy metals like cadmium in chemical phosphate fertilizers may be the cause of these adverse effects. The discovery has left scientists questioning the potential health implications of organic food and whether it truly offers better benefits for human consumers.
Read more to find out: